| Artist | Album | Title | Label | New |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Free Design | You Could Be Born Again | Close Your Mouth It's Christmas | Light in the Attic | No |
| The Bran Flakes | single | Here Comes Santa | self release | No |
| Eddie Lawrence | Christmas Novelty Classics | Merry Old Philosopher #1 | Master Classics | No |
| Sufjan Stevens | Songs For Christmas, Vol. 10: Christmas Unicorn | Up on the Housetop | Asthmatic Kitty | Yes |
| Bob & Doug McKenzie | Great White North | 12 Days of Christmas | Island/Mercury | No |
| Jimmy Butler | Blues, Blues Christmas (1925-1955) | Trim Your Tree | Document | No |
| Bob Rivers | Bob Rivers & Twisted Radio | Teddy the Red-Nosed Senator | Rhino Atlantic | No |
| Esquivel | Merry Xmas From the Space-Age Bachelor Pad | Frosty the Snowman | Bar/None | No |
| The Polyphonic Spree | Holiday Dream: Sounds of the Holidays, Vol 1 | Let It Snow | Kirtland | Yes |
| Margo Guryan | 25 Demos | I Don't Intend To Spend Christmas Without You | Oglie Entertainment | No |
| Belle & Sebastian | single | O Come, O Emmanuel | Jeepster | No |
| Darien Welch | single | Man With the Bell | self release | No |
| Best Coast & Wavves | single | Got Something For You | Target | No |
| The Pac-Man Family | Pac-Man Christmas Album | Snowflakes & Frozen Lakes | Kid Stuff | No |
| Jingle Cats | Meowy Christmas | Dance of the Sugarplum Fairies | Jingle Cats Music | No |
| Star Wars | Christmas In The Stars: Star Wars Christmas Album | R2-D2 We Wish You a Merry Christmas | Rhino/WEA | No |
| Crocodiles & Dum Dum Girls | single | Merry Christmas Baby (Please Don't Die) | Hell Yes! Records | No |
| Woods | single | Christmas Time Is Here | Woodsist | No |
| Gruff Rhys | Atheist Xmas EP | Post Apocalypse Christmas | Wichita | No |
| Teenage Fanclub | Various-Big Star Small World | Jesus Christ | Koch | No |
| Sufjan Stevens | Songs For Christmas Vol. 10: Christmas Unicorn | Christmas Unicorn | Asthmatic Kitty | Yes |
| Sera Cahoone | Deer Creek Canyon | Naked | Sub Pop | No |
| Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds | single | We No Who U R | Bad Seed Ltd. | No |
| GRMLN | Explore | Summer Nights | Carpark | No |
| Gene Loves Jezebel | Kiss of Life | Two Shadows | Geffen/Beggars Banquet | No |
| Leland | This is My World | Drain the Truth From Me | Contempt | No |
| Gorky's Zygotic Mynci | Introducing Gorky's Zygotic Mynci | Kevin Ayers | Mercury | No |
| Those Darlins | single | Summer's Dead | Oh Wow Dang Records | No |
| Biggi Hilmars | All We Can Be | Now Is the Time | Biggi Music | No |
| Of Montreal | Daughter Of Cloud | Our Love Is Senile | Polyvinyl | Yes |
| Callers | Reviver | Howard 2 Hands | Partisan | Yes |
| Unnatural Helpers | Land Grab | Waiting Girl | Hardly Art | Yes |
Also new, but not marked as new since they are not currently in rotation: Sera Cahoone, Nick Cave, GRMLN, Those Darlins & Biggi Hilmars